Pure Magnolias

Book Review: The Summer of Broken Rules by K.L. Walther

If you’re looking for the ultimate summer romance filled with Taylor Swift vibes, swoon-worthy moments, and a heartwarming mix of love, loss, and friendship, then The Summer of Broken Rules is the perfect book to add to your TBR! It’s like a warm, sunny day wrapped up in pages—light, fun, emotional, and totally unforgettable.

About the Book

Meredith Fox has spent every summer on Martha’s Vineyard with her family, but this year is different. It’s the first summer without her sister Claire, and she’s not sure she’s ready for all the emotions that come with returning.

To keep her mind off the sadness, Meredith throws herself into her family’s legendary game of assassin—a high-stakes competition where everyone is out to eliminate their targets. But what she doesn’t expect? A charming, blue-eyed groomsman who just might make her believe in love again.

As the wedding week unfolds, Meredith finds herself caught between playing to win and falling for someone who could change everything. It’s a summer of new beginnings, unexpected romance, and learning that love—like the best games—is always a little unpredictable.

Clean Content & Age Recommendation

• Age Recommendation: 12+
• Spice Rating: Very mild—just some sweet kissing and adorable romantic tension
• Language: Minimal and clean
• Violence: Only playful competition (think water balloons and sneaky eliminations in the assassin game)
• Romance: Lighthearted, summery, and full of adorable boy-next-door vibes

This book is perfect for readers who love a feel-good romance that’s heartfelt but totally clean.

Things to Keep in Mind

• Taylor Swift Lovers, Rejoice! This book is packed with folklore and Lover energy, with references to Taylor’s songs that set the perfect summer soundtrack.
• Beachy, Summer Wedding Aesthetic Think flowy dresses, sunset walks, and the dreamiest island setting ever.
• Themes of Grief & Healing While the book is light and romantic, it also touches on loss in a gentle and meaningful way.
• Swoony Love Interest Alert! The romance is slow-burn, flirty, and oh-so-cute (think To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before meets The Summer I Turned Pretty).

Final Thoughts

The Summer of Broken Rules is the perfect beach read—fun, heartfelt, and overflowing with sunshine and love. If you’re in the mood for a sweet YA romance with strong family bonds, a little bit of adventure, and a love story straight out of a rom-com, this one is a must-read!

Five stars—a dreamy, feel-good summer romance that’s as sweet as an ice cream cone on a hot day!

Check out my shop at: https://puremagnolias.printful.me !